Hunter Biden.Photo: Paul Morigi/Getty
More than a year after announcing that he wasunder federal investigationrelated to his taxes, PresidentJoe Biden’s sonHunter Bidenremains the subject of an ongoing and intensifying probe,according tovariousnewsreports and sources connected to the case.
Much remains unclear, however, including what potential criminal liability Hunter faces — if any. He has not been charged.
Prosecutors have long declined to publicly discuss their work, and Hunter’s attorneys and spokespeople have not commented.
“I take this matter very seriously,” Hunter, 52, said in a statement in December 2020, “but I am confident that a professional and objective review of these matters will demonstrate that I handled my affairs legally and appropriately, including with the benefit of professional tax advisors.”
Hunter, a prominent attorney and businessman-turned-painter with ahistory of personal struggles, has for years been the source of scrutiny and derision among conservatives, despite having no official role in in his dad’s campaign or now in the White House.
Republicans homed in, in particular, on his overseas business dealings which overlapped with his father’s vice presidency and his problems with drug use and other personal matters, which became tabloid fodder in large part thanks to a purported copy of a laptop that used to belong to him and which is said to be full of his intimate records.
Hunter was also a reluctant focus of the face-off between his father and former PresidentDonald Trump, whosefirst impeachment stemmedfrom urging Ukraine to dig up dirt on Hunter.
In December 2020, when Hunter disclosed the investigation, President Biden’s team released their own statement saying he “is deeply proud of his son, who has fought through difficult challenges, including the vicious personal attacks of recent months, only to emerge stronger.”
Here’s what is known and not known about the case surrounding Hunter.
Hunter (left) and Joe Biden.Teresa Kroeger/Getty
A Years-Long Investigation About Money
In his 2020 statement, Hunter said that he had only just learned “that the U.S. Attorney’s Office … [is] investigating my tax affairs.”
Sources told ABC News andThe New York Timesthat the matter began much earlier, though the exact date varies.
Hunter’s business dealings with foreign interests, including acting as a well-connected consultant — a topic that was much-discussed in the lead-up the2020 presidential election— also reportedly drew scrutiny from authorities.
The Washington Postwrote last monththat, per sources, “federal prosecutors had been attempting to determine if [Hunter] failed to account for income from China-related deals … although it is unclear whether that is still a focus.”
The investigation became public only after the 2020 election because of longstanding concerns among federal authorities that their work could influence voters (an issue that was raised regardingHillary Clintonduring the 2016 campaign).
Huntertold CBS News in April 2021that he was “fully cooperating, and I’m fully confident that at the end of the day it’s all gonna be fine.”
Since then, authorities have continued their work: ABC News reported in March that “an increasing number of witnesses have appeared before a grand jury impaneled in Wilmington, Delaware, in recent months.”
Among the topics guiding that testimony were questions “about payments Hunter Biden received while serving on the board of directors of Ukrainian natural gas company Burisma, in addition to other questions about how [he] paid off tax obligations in recent years,” per ABC News' sources.
Witnesses in the case includeLunden Roberts, an Arkansas woman who used to work with Hunter and who had a child with him in 2018. She later successfully sued him for paternity and financial support after he publicly denied being the child’s father.
Roberts' attorney, Clint Lancaster, told PEOPLE that Roberts recently testified in the Hunter investigation and that he was subpoenaed to provide financial records from Hunter obtained as part of the separate paternity suit.
Lancaster — a self-described conservative who maintains that his personal politics have no role in his work with Roberts — declined to discuss in further detail his knowledge of the federal investigation or of the financial records provided under subpoena.
Hunter Biden.Paul Morigi/Getty Images
Big Questions Remain
While recent reporting indicates the investigation is both broader than Hunter’s tax payments and is still proceeding apace, that is not evidence itself of any wrongdoing.
There is no public indication Hunter will face an indictment and the specifics of any possible charge against Hunter are also not clear.
TheTimesandThe Wall Street Journalboth reported last month that he had paid off a major tax bill — theJournalwrote that it was approximately $1 million — which could complicate a future prosecution because jurors would see it as showing contrition and responsibility.
TheTimesalso wrote that prosecutors could be looking at other subjects beyond Hunter, including other companies, as part of their work.
Hunter has previously admitted that some of his past business dealings showed “poor judgment” because they created even the appearance of impropriety, given his dad’s political career.
But he insists that he “did nothing wrong.”
“In retrospect, look, I think that it was poor judgment on my part,” Huntertold ABC News Anchor Amy Robachin October 2019. “Is that I think that it was poor judgment because I don’t believe now, when I look back on it — I know that there was — did nothing wrong at all. However, was it poor judgment to be in the middle of something that is … a swamp in many ways? Yeah.”
The Laptop
Some of the latest reports about the investigation cite contents from a laptop that is said to have once belonged to Hunter. This convoluted chapter, which dates back to the 2020 presidential campaign, appears related to the current case only in that the laptop seems to contain records about Hunter’s past business dealings.
Hunter has never confirmed the laptop belonged to him, though he has acknowledged it is a possibility.
TheTimesand theWashington Postmore recently wrote they were able to verify some of the records on the laptop, citing the assessment of outside experts.
More specifically, though, thePostwrote that “nearly 22,000 emails” had the markings of authenticity, per the experts, though more than 200,000 other files could not be verified.
Many mainstream news outlets initially resisted reporting on the contents of the laptop during the 2020 campaign, and social media companies like Facebook and Twitter worked to limit the spread of the outlets that did over concerns about the provenance and veracity of the reporting. Republicans, in turn, said a legitimate news story was being suppressed because it was about Democrats.
Hunter Biden (center) holding son Beau.Tom Williams/CQ-Roll Call, Inc via Getty
Hunter’s Life Away from D.C.
Hunter has spoken openly about his struggles with addiction, which became public during and after his 2017 divorce from his first wifeKathleen Buhle, who alleged in legal filings that he had spent money on drugs, alcohol, prostitutes and strip clubs.
Hunter — who shares daughters Naomi, Finnegan and Maisy with Buhle — wrote about his cycle of addiction and sobriety in his 2021 memoir,Beautiful Things. He wrote at one point that he was drinking a quart of vodka a day; at another, helived with a homeless womanwho was also his dealer.
Some sources said in the latest news reports about the investigation that his past issues with substance abuse may influence authorities insofar as it could indicate he had compromised decision-making.
Hunter has since spoken about finding new peace and stability — and enduring sobriety — while living on the West Coast, where he spends his time painting and raising a young son (named after his late brother, Beau) with wifeMelissa Cohen.
source: people.com
